Partial canon

Sara's Voices

Character / Mechanic

The most direct line to MIY's mind. Reactivated this season.

 Updated through S4E6

Sara Myers and her voices are the show's earliest fully.disclosed supernatural mechanic. In S1 she heard voices that compelled her to harm others, including the attack on Ethan and the killing of her brother Nathan. Father Khatri treated the voices as a possible communication channel. He died protecting her. The voices were quiet through S2.S3, until S4E4 when Sophia whispered something inaudibly in her ear and they returned.

After S4E6

Julie spends much of the episode with Sara, painting her house. Reading this charitably: Julie may be the only person whose presence creates a quiet space where MIY's voice loses purchase. Reading it darkly: the calm is preparation for a larger role.

What's confirmed in canon

S1Voices compel Sara to harm others. Attacks Ethan; kills her brother Nathan.

S1Father Khatri hides her in the church basement. Treats voices as a channel.

S1 finaleFather Khatri dies protecting Sara during the Colony House attack.

S4E4Sophia whispers; voices return. Source now confirmed to be MIY.

Where the community lands

Voices being MIY's is confirmed. Open: what Khatri got right vs wrong about them being a channel rather than just control.

Still open

Q1Was Khatri right that the voices are a channel?

Q2Is Sara a future vessel for MIY?

Q3What was the original bargain her killing of Nathan was part of?

Q4Why was MIY silent for two seasons?

Connected entities

The Man in Yellow The Boy in White Randall Kirkland The Reincarnation Cycle Donna Raines Fatima Hassan Father Khatri Boyd Stevens

Connections graph

Full graph

Laying out…

Have a theory about Sara's Voices?

Lock in a prediction, weigh in on the open theories, or get an alert the moment new canon lands.

Make a prediction Weigh in on theories

Follow Sara's Voices

Get an alert when From confirms or debunks a theory about Sara's Voices.